A Song Is Born (1948)


Bil’s rating (out of 5): BBB

USA, 1948. . Screenplay by , based on the story From A To Z by , . Cinematography by . Produced by . Music by , . Production Design by , . Costume Design by . Film Editing by .

Howard Hawks takes his 1941 comedy Ball Of Fire and turns its jazzy Snow White plot into a Technicolor musical, with filling in for Gary Cooper as one of a group of housebound eggheads who in this version are music historians instead of linguists. The men are busy at work on a comprehensive history of music around the world when two window washers (played by the comedic team of Buck and Bubbles) enter their hallowed domain and introduce them to the wonders of modern jazz. Realizing that a whole shift has happened in the artform since they began their project, Kaye decides to venture out to the city’s nightclubs to learn more about the up-tempo rhythms of the genre, making the rounds from place to place and asking the various acts he meets (which include the likes of , , and all playing themselves) to come back to his institute to help with his research.

He also meets a hot nightclub singer ( in place of Barbara Stanwyck) who holes up in the musty old house of studious professors to hide from the law, as her gangster boyfriend () is suspected of murder and the cops want her for questioning. Mayo slides right in to an easy life with these gentlemen, helping out with the study sessions (which exist as good excuses for some fun musical numbers) while pretending to fall in love with Kaye in order to help her cover story. The problem is, of course, that he genuinely falls for her and she eventually can’t help but be won over by his naïve, good-natured sincerity.

While this is hardly the jewel in Hawks’ directorial crown, and in fact is a project he was coerced into making and brought little passion to it, it’s a worthy retelling of one of his brightest comedies, the production numbers have snap and show off the talents of some of the finest artists in popular music of the time, and Kaye still manages to stand out for his sharp comedic talents despite being threatened with an overpowering supporting cast of no end of terrific supporting characters.

The main disappointment is that Hawks places Mayo’s character far more in the background than was the case in the original version, and Mayo isn’t a strong enough actor to survive the challenge: confident, glamorous and enjoying marvelous chemistry with her frequent co-star, Mayo doesn’t have the street-smart sizzle that made Stanwyck both sympathetic and terrifying at the same time, and without that electric charge (most evident in the very limp version of the “yum-yum” scene) the rest of the film is forced to be that much more charming to justify its own existence.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s