Bil’s rating (out of 5): BBB.5. USA, 1984. David Foster Productions, Jalem Productions, Operation Cork, Turman-Foster Company. Screenplay by Bill C. Davis, based on his play. Cinematography by Donald Peterman. Produced by David Foster, Lawrence Turman. Music by Bill Conti. Production Design by Philip M. Jefferies. Costume Design by Shari Feldman, Bruce Walkup. Film Editing by John Wright. National Board of Review Awards 1984.
Superb performances are the best thing about this intelligent and sensitive drama. After two male seminary students are expelled from their school for being lovers, another student (Zeljko Ivanek) calls the Catholic church’s stance on sexual relationships into question and has heated debates about it with a sympathetic priest (Jack Lemmon). Written by Bill C. Davis from his own play, the film addresses issues of archaic religion in a modern context and has two characters whose own faith is constantly at war with their common sense. Great interplay between the two leads, especially with Davis’s excellent dialogue, though the material tends to be a bit too obvious with its message to come across all that smoothly to an audience.