BBB.5
(out of 5)
The ancient tradition of coming-of-age stories is once again trotted out as Eddie Redmayne abandons his aristocratic homestead in the country and heads to Pinewood Studios in search of his dream of making it in the movies. Thanks to family connections and his own dogged determination to not be turned away, he wheedles his way onto the set of Laurence Olivier’s new production of The Sleeping Prince (later to be retitled The Prince and The Showgirl) and finds himself not only in the presence of the century’s most famous British actor and director (embodied here by Kenneth Branagh) but also the world’s most famous woman, Marilyn Monroe (Michelle Williams). Monroe arrives on the scene and becomes everyone’s biggest problem: her insistence on finding her way into a near-fairy-tale character through the Method (with her gorgon of an acting coach Paula Strasberg, played by Zoë Wanamaker, in tow) makes her Olivier’s greatest nightmare, not to mention that this is the point where the combination of her volatile personality and her increasing reliance on substances was beginning to take its toll. Redmayne, in spending time with the starlet and falling deeply in puppy love with her, also notices that the two giants at the head of this project are at war because of a deep, fundamental insecurity they share: he, Redmayne points out, is a great actor who wants to be a movie star, and she is a movie star who wants desperately to be a great actress. The young man’s combination of enthusiasm and charm captures the twinkle in the great icon’s eye and she spends a few days letting him in to see the little girl behind the glamorous mask: or does she? This film follows the “I was never the same again after that summer” narrative with such alarming familiarity (right down to the opening and closing narration told from the point of view of a wiser perspective) that it should not be nearly as mesmerizing as it is, nor should the performances be as enjoyable as they are given the minimal verisimilitude they bear to their real-life counterparts. Branagh does a terrific accent as Olivier but does not have his imposing stature or graceful bearing, Judi Dench‘s Sybil Thorndike reveals her to be as delightful in life as she was in the film but she is the opposite of Thorndike’s fine-boned eccentricity, and Julia Ormond is superb as Vivien Leigh but fails to recall the twinkly-eyed coquette that was starting to fade at this point in time. As the icon at the centre of the story, Williams gives a richly layered, fascinating portrayal of the world’s greatest movie star that captures the woman’s nature but does not go far enough in re-enacting the goddess: she’s beautiful and the makeup effects are impressive, but Williams does not have the luminous quality that Marilyn possessed (perhaps it’s in the eyes—Williams has a solid, steady gaze while much of Marilyn’s rocket-ship charisma came from the fact that hers were never sure if they were miserable or elated). If they were not all based on real people these actors would probably come off better, but the film does not suffer greatly for these flaws. Redmayne is so terribly likable that he makes the old feel new again, and the screenplay does a wise job of creating a rich character of “Marilyn Monroe” that reflects the ambivalence of her being the “Little Girl Lost” at the same time that she was a ferociously selfish mess. Watching her navigate between these extremes, and watching to see if Redmayne will survive them, is actually exciting; in the film’s best sequence, they spend a day visiting Eton and she quickly whispers, “Shall I be her?” before wiggling her famous tush to a group of the school’s starstruck staff members. Beyond that, the recreations of scenes from The Prince and The Showgirl are quite impressive, and the nostalgia-tinged cinematography is pristine.
The Weinstein Company, BBC Films, Lipsync Productions, Trademark Films, UK Film Council
United Kingdom/USA, 2011
Directed by Simon Curtis
Screenplay by Adrian Hodges, based on the books My Week With Marilyn and The Prince, The Showgirl and Me by Colin Clark
Cinematography by Ben Smithard
Produced by David Parfitt, Harvey Weinstein
Music by Conrad Pope
Production Design by Donal Woods
Costume Design by Jill Taylor
Film Editing by Adam Recht
Cast Tags: Adam Perry, Alex Lowe, Ben Sando, Brooks Livermore, David Rintoul, Derek Jacobi, Des McAleer, Dominic Cooper, Dougray Scott, Eddie Redmayne, Emma Watson, Georgie Glen, Geraldine Somerville, Gerard Horan, James Clay, Jem Wall, Jim Carter, Josh Morris, Judi Dench, Julia Ormond, Karl Moffatt, Kenneth Branagh, Michael Hobbs, Michael Kitchen, Michelle Williams, Miranda Raison, New York Film Critics 2011, Paul Herzberg, Penny Ryder, Peter Wight, Philip Jackson, Pip Torrens, Richard Attlee, Richard Clifford, Richard Shelton, Robert Portal, Rod O’Grady, Sean Vanderwilt, Simon Russell Beale, Toby Jones, Victor McGuire, Zoë Wanamaker
Academy Award Nominations
Best Actor in a Supporting Role (Kenneth Branagh as “Sir Laurence Olivier”)
Best Actress in a Supporting Role (Michelle Williams as “Marilyn Monroe”)
Golden Globe Award
Best Performance By An Actress in a Motion Picture-Comedy or Musical (Michelle Williams)
Nominations
Best Motion Picture-Comedy or Musical
Best Performance by an Actor in a Supporting Role in a Motion Picture (Kenneth Branagh)
New York Film Critics Award Nominations
Best Actress (Michelle Williams)
Best First Film
Screen Actors Guild Award Nominations
Outstanding Performance by a Female Actor in a Leading Role (Michelle Williams)
Outstanding Performance by a Male Actor in a Supporting Role (Kenneth Branagh)
Independent Spirit Award
Best Female Lead (Michelle Williams)
British Academy Award Nominations
Best Leading Actress (Michelle Williams)
Best Supporting Actor (Kenneth Branagh)
Best Supporting Actress (Judi Dench)
Best Costume Design
Best Make Up & Hair
Alexander Korda Award for Best British Film
Toronto Film Critics Award
Best Actress (Michelle Williams)
Boston Film Critics Award
Best Actress (Michelle Williams)
Chicago Film Critics Award
Best Actress (Michelle Williams)
Nomination
Most Promising Filmmaker
